No. 46 in makeup
Benefit Precisely My Brow Pencil
// glowrecs.com/benefit-precisely-my-brow
Buy on Amazon See price
Affiliate link. We earn a commission on Amazon purchases — rankings are based on Reddit consensus, not commission rates. How it works.
Sentiment analysis in progress
10 Reddit mentions · 8 threads · 4 subs
95% CI: 0–0%
★3.5 on Amazon (42 reviews)
Why we ranked it No. 46 in makeup
Sample 10 redditors with explicit opinion · 0 positive · 0 negative · 0 neutral
Confidence95% CI: 0–0% · the true approval rate falls in this range with 95% statistical confidence
Verdict Reddit Confirmed — Threshold-based label from our methodology.
Sources r/Makeup, r/MakeupRehab, r/Ulta, r/BeautyGuruChatter
Benefit · makeup
Reddit Confirmed

Precisely My Brow Pencil

r/Makeupr/MakeupRehabr/Ultar/BeautyGuruChatter
TL;DR — Reddit consensus
Ultra-fine brow pencil for hair-like strokes — the one Benefit product Reddit names by name. Catalog listing.
What redditors love
+
Precise hair-like strokes even for sparse brows
“t medium coverage serum concealer, really hydrating. i have shades 19 and 20 and there is hardly any difference between them, 19 is very slightly pinker. 8/30: benefit precisely my brow pencil - this is just ok. it's not a bad price for being half off but it's too waxy for me. clinique almost lipsti”
u/gryffyryne · r/Ulta →
What they don’t
Tiny product amount for the price
Read all 10 mentions on Reddit ↓
Direct quotes

What 8 redditors actually said.

Top 6 by confidence shown — expand below for the rest. Click any to open the original on Reddit.
G
u/gryffyryne · r/Ulta
t medium coverage serum concealer, really hydrating. i have shades 19 and 20 and there is hardly any difference between them, 19 is very slightly pinker. 8/30: benefit precisely my brow pencil - this is just ok. it's not a bad price for being half off but it's too waxy for me. clinique almost lipstick in black honey -
View thread →
1
u/1992LDN · r/BeautyGuruChatter
benefit precisely my brow is by far the best brow pencil on the market followed by nyx micro brow!
View thread →
L
u/LoudCloudLady · r/Makeup
ere’s my must haves atm surratt stick highlighter too faced bronzing stick in milk chocolate for contour or westman atelier biscuit rare beauty eyebrow gel and benefit precisely my brow in cool grey ct setting spray tartelette xl mascara tower 28 concealer ud eyeshadow primer potion ct lipliner in iconic nude valentino
View thread →
M
u/magnoliasmum · r/Makeup
at buildable. a little fenty powder to set. a little powder or cream blush, depends on my mood. powder is faster. i use pale, cool toned shades. brows with the benefit precisely my brow pencil. curl lashes with shiseido curler. one thin, thin coat of covergirl lash blast clean waterproof mascara in whatever the blackes
View thread →
K
u/kirapizza · r/Makeup
i was a “drug store brow pencils are the same as high end” truther until i recently finally tried the benefit precisely my brow. not too warm like the nyx one, glides on easily, and long lasting
View thread →
C
u/celebwen · r/MakeupRehab
week, def need to get a replacement lined up. 1. rum mascara in black 2. chanel no1 lip and cheek pot in vital beige 3. besame translucent powder in violet 4. benefit precisely my brow in 4.5 5. ~~nars cream shadow stick in don't touch~~ 6. necessaire santal body lotion 7. verden magnesium body balm 8. summer fridays
View thread →