No. 58
in makeup
Buy on Amazon
See price
● Affiliate link.
We earn a commission on Amazon purchases — rankings are based on Reddit consensus, not commission rates.
How it works.
Sentiment analysis in progress
Why we ranked it No. 58 in makeup
Sample
3 redditors with explicit opinion · 0 positive · 0 negative · 0 neutral
Confidence95% CI: 0–0% · the true approval rate falls in this range with 95% statistical confidence
Verdict
Reddit Confirmed — Threshold-based label from our methodology.
Sources
r/Makeup, r/Sephora, r/SkincareAddictionUK
Benefit · makeup
Reddit Confirmed
They're Real! Lengthening Mascara
r/Makeupr/Sephorar/SkincareAddictionUK
TL;DR — Reddit consensus
Lengthening mascara with a cult past — still named in holy-grail threads, though waterproof-grade removal divides users.
What redditors love
+
Length and separation without clumps
“at80042) * [anastasia beverly hills best brows ever kit](https://www.ulta.com/best-brows-ever-kit?productid=pimprod2010228&sku=2554796&categoryid=cat260010) * [benefit cosmetics they're real! lengthening mascara](https://www.ulta.com/theyre-real-lengthening-mascara?productid=xlsimpprod3460265&sku=22”
u/A2J7T9J5 · r/Makeup →
What they don’t
−
Notoriously hard to remove — tugging risk
“ation but today i did so thought it was a good chance to test. it removed all makeup very well including fenty pro filt'r foundation, shape tape concealer, and benefit they're real mascara. small amount of eyeliner was left along the lash line that's all.”
u/mmm095 · r/SkincareAddictionUK →
Direct quotes
What 4 redditors actually said.
Top 4 by confidence shown — expand below for the rest. Click any to open the original on Reddit.
A
u/A2J7T9J5
·
r/Makeup
at80042) * [anastasia beverly hills best brows ever kit](https://www.ulta.com/best-brows-ever-kit?productid=pimprod2010228&sku=2554796&categoryid=cat260010) * [benefit cosmetics they're real! lengthening mascara](https://www.ulta.com/theyre-real-lengthening-mascara?productid=xlsimpprod3460265&sku=2231443&categoryid=cat
[
u/[deleted]
·
r/Makeup
benefit they're real! i literally look like i have fake lashes on when i built it on my already pretty long lashes though so you have to be careful not to overdo it.
S
u/skyerippa
·
r/Sephora
my eyelashes fall out from too faced mascaras which sucks cause i loved one of them. can't remember which one now though oops im wrong it was benefit, they're really and another benefit one. i loved they're real so much but legit all my eyelashes started falling out i took a break from it and got a new tube
M
u/mmm095
·
r/SkincareAddictionUK
ation but today i did so thought it was a good chance to test. it removed all makeup very well including fenty pro filt'r foundation, shape tape concealer, and benefit they're real mascara. small amount of eyeliner was left along the lash line that's all.
Threads tracked
The conversations we're watching.
Read also
Reddit deep-dives that mention this product.
Adjacent
Often mentioned in the same threads.
Out of stock on Amazon
02
URBAN DECAY
All Nighter Setting Spray
The setting spray Reddit names for events, heat and 12-hour days — the one Milani gets compared to.
★ · 1.7k Amazon reviews
Out of stock on Amazon
03
TIRTIR
Mask Fit Red Cushion
The viral red cushion — 54 redditors on the TikTok-famous glow finish; AI Overview names it the cushion to buy.
★ · 38.2k Amazon reviews
Buy on Amazon
See price
