Out of stock on Amazon. Reddit verdict and quotes below stay live — we'll re-link as soon as a verified replacement passes our 6-gate validation.
No. 45 in makeup
ColourPop Super Shock Shadow
// glowrecs.com/colourpop-super-shock-shadow
Out of stock on Amazon
Affiliate link. We earn a commission on Amazon purchases — rankings are based on Reddit consensus, not commission rates. How it works.
Sentiment analysis in progress
25 Reddit mentions · 5 threads · 3 subs
95% CI: 0–66%
★4.4 on Amazon (133 reviews)
Why we ranked it No. 45 in makeup
Sample 25 redditors with explicit opinion · 0 positive · 2 negative · 0 neutral
Confidence95% CI: 0–66% · the true approval rate falls in this range with 95% statistical confidence
Verdict Reddit Confirmed — Threshold-based label from our methodology.
Sources r/MakeupRehab, r/Makeup, r/BeautyGuruChatter
ColourPop · makeup
Reddit Confirmed

Super Shock Shadow

r/MakeupRehabr/Makeupr/BeautyGuruChatter
TL;DR — Reddit consensus
Bouncy cream-powder shadows — Reddit's budget pigment legend, $7 a pot.
What redditors love
+
Pigment payoff that embarrasses $30 shadows
“ost mentioned other eyeshadows:** 1. dose of colors block party single shadows 2. tarte chrome paint shadow pots 3. tie: colourpop jelly much eyeshadow singles colourpop super shock shadows hourglass scattered light glitter eyeshadow inglot x jlo pure pigment eye shadow pixi by petra liquid fairy li”
u/puddlepuddle · r/BeautyGuruChatter →
+
Minimal fallout for the intensity
What they don’t
Dries out in the pot over months
“- used a few times 6. carmex tube. i don't buy carmex anymore - cut open, should be done soon 7. quem disse berenice liquid glitter - used a couple of times 8. colourpop super shock highlighter in double down - only used once or twice 10. lemon meringue body spray - used several times; shouldn't be ”
u/rudegirlmakeup · r/MakeupRehab →
Read all 25 mentions on Reddit ↓
Direct quotes

What 8 redditors actually said.

Top 6 by confidence shown — expand below for the rest. Click any to open the original on Reddit.
R
u/rudegirlmakeup · r/MakeupRehab
- used a few times 6. carmex tube. i don't buy carmex anymore - cut open, should be done soon 7. quem disse berenice liquid glitter - used a couple of times 8. colourpop super shock highlighter in double down - only used once or twice 10. lemon meringue body spray - used several times; shouldn't be hard to finish
View thread →
R
u/rudegirlmakeup · r/MakeupRehab
don't buy carmex anymore. i've had this at my desk for some time. 7. quem disse berenice liquid glitter - already having to scrape at the sides of the tube. 8. colourpop super shock highlighter in double down - mostly pan, with only a small amount of product left; yet i keep forgetting to finish it off. 9. collection e
View thread →
I
u/InsuranceMountain956 · r/MakeupRehab
n glace - finish |** i got this as a sephora gift and bite beauty has been out of business for years so....time to get her out of my collection! 85% left. 4. **colourpop super shock shadow twitterpated - finish |** this has been sitting untouched in my collection for years with a hard pan. if i don't use it up by the e
View thread →
P
u/puddlepuddle · r/BeautyGuruChatter
ost mentioned other eyeshadows:** 1. dose of colors block party single shadows 2. tarte chrome paint shadow pots 3. tie: colourpop jelly much eyeshadow singles colourpop super shock shadows hourglass scattered light glitter eyeshadow inglot x jlo pure pigment eye shadow pixi by petra liquid fairy lights   **most m
View thread →
P
u/puddlepuddle · r/BeautyGuruChatter
ned eyeshadow primer:** covergirl lip lock up eyeshadow primer   **top 3 most mentioned highlighters:** 1. anastasia beverly hills x amrezy highlighter 2. colourpop super shock highlighter 3. becca shimmering skin perfector pressed highlighter   **most mentioned lashes:** house of lashes   **top 3 most m
View thread →
A
u/A2J7T9J5 · r/Makeup
8) * [morphe liquid lipstick - true story (rich caramel)](https://www.ulta.com/liquid-lipstick?productid=xlsimpprod19101065&sku=2535277&categoryid=cat80058) * [colourpop super shock shadow - ladybird (soft ivory with multi-dimensional silver glitter)](https://www.ulta.com/super-shock-shadow?productid=xlsimpprod17801019
View thread →