No. 13
in skincare
Buy on Amazon
See price
● Affiliate link.
We earn a commission on Amazon purchases — rankings are based on Reddit consensus, not commission rates.
How it works.
82% would recommend
Why we ranked it No. 13 in skincare
Sample
135 redditors with explicit opinion · 46 positive · 9 negative · 1 neutral
Score0.825 — formula: 0.75 × % positive + 0.25 × pos/neg ratio
Confidence95% CI: 70–90% · the true approval rate falls in this range with 95% statistical confidence
Verdict
Highly Recommended — ≥65% positive across ≥7 redditors.
Sources
r/AsianBeauty, r/KoreanBeauty, r/tretinoin, r/SkincareAddiction, r/40PlusSkinCare + 2 more
Haruharu · skincare
Highly Recommended
Wonder Black Rice Serum
r/AsianBeautyr/KoreanBeautyr/tretinoinr/SkincareAddictionr/40PlusSkinCarer/IndianSkincareAddicts
TL;DR — Reddit consensus
Hydrating black rice toner/essence that layers beautifully without feeling heavy. Some find it watery or pricey, and authenticity issues reported on Amazon.
What redditors love
+
Most hydrating toner without heaviness or residue
“Most hydrating toner I've ever used”
u/Intelligent_Line7212 · r/IndianSkincareAddicts →
+
Long-lasting hydration that keeps skin plump
“this is beautiful. long-last”
u/softhorns · r/AsianBeauty →
+
Thicker consistency serves dry skin better than lighter toners
“the thicker HaruHaru toner is really serving my skin better”
u/Sweet--Olive · r/AsianBeauty →
+
Brand consistently delivers across multiple products in routine
“Haruharu is slowly creeping in my routine product by product! Love everything by this br”
u/lifeof_louisewalton · r/KoreanBeauty →
What they don’t
−
Amazon storefront now sells watery inauthentic versions
“The one I got thru Amazon (the Haruharu store front) was much more water'y if that makes sense. Not as soothing and sof”
u/Ina99GoBoy · r/AsianBeauty →
−
Probiotics essence version caused severe irritation
“the Haru Haru Wonder Probiotics Barrier Essence irritated my skin so so so much”
u/cowrunamuck · r/KoreanBeauty →
−
Price point higher than comparable hydrating toners
“Too pricey tho”
u/Intelligent_Line7212 · r/IndianSkincareAddicts →
−
Some find texture too watery with minimal effect
“it just felt like water to me”
u/Intelligent_Line7212 · r/IndianSkincareAddicts →
COMPARE WITH
Cheaper alternative
Good Molecules
Good Molecules ha serum
→
Premium pick
Beauty of Joseon
Beauty of Joseon eye serum
→
Direct quotes
What 56 redditors actually said.
Top 6 by confidence shown — expand below for the rest. Click any to open the original on Reddit.
C
u/CommunicationIcy7757
·
r/KoreanBeauty
Skin 1004 hya-cica spf, haruharu unscented toner, numbuzin no 3 serum. Regularly repurchase so I never run out.
P
u/Pretend-Complex6816
·
r/AsianBeauty
How to decide??? I love this problem. I became obsessed with Haru Haru Wonder Black Rice Probiotics Barrier Essence as a milky toner, used it down to the last drop. My
S
u/Select_Friendship_22
·
r/AsianBeauty
Not at all , it totally did products imo I ended up using haruharu on my body , never repurchased . I hate that film on my skin , couldn’t use it
A
u/AnyNecessary3732
·
r/AsianBeauty
er K brands like Tirtir and Lanage, but I haven't yet. I'm too in love with the Haruharu.
S
u/Sufficient-Pen596
·
r/AsianBeauty
have extremely extremely sensitive skin, EVERYTHING breaks me out. I tried the haruharu black rice toner (yes, fragrance free) but it still broke me out. Other product
E
u/Ehloanna
·
r/AsianBeauty
I will die before I give up my haruharu black rice probiotic barrier essence. Literally one of the nicest things I've e
Show all 56 mentions ↓
"May i ask what website you use to order your toners :)? I love the haruharu one but i def want to try the zipiderm one now! I just so happen to be on empty"
View thread →
"- Haruharu wonder toner (on my 9th jumbo bottle)
- Haruharu airy fit sunscreen (more on the moisurizing side)
- Beauty of joseon aqua sunsc"
View thread →
"I’m sad to say the Haru Haru Wonder Probiotics Barrier Essence irritated my skin so so so much. I read all the bad r"
View thread →
"Zeroid Intensive Cream, CosRx Propolis Synergy Toner, Haruharu 5.5 cleansing gel and Erborian CC Correct! I have acne + rosacea and these prod"
View thread →
"Haruharu is slowly creeping in my routine product by product! Love everything by this br"
View thread →
"I second haruharu- I bought it maybe a month ago on advice from this sub, and it is truly great."
View thread →
"The haruharu black rice sensitive line…god tier. The skincare I like are just breakfast ingr"
View thread →
"entella Toner-unscented*- this product is superb for calming irritated skin.
*HaruHaru Probiotics Barrier Essence*- this product is beyond compare, in my opinion. I c"
View thread →
"t know about HG but routinely been using and repurchasing these: BOJ sunscreen, Haruharu Triple AHAs cleansing gel, Cos De Baha snail mucin (in a big pump), Abib overni"
View thread →
"BEWARE Haruharu Amazon shop now sells inauthentic products I have purchased from the Haruharu A"
View thread →
"ot have sensitive skin, it just felt like water to me
- **3/10**
---
### 8. Haru Haru Wonder Black Rice Toner:
- Most hydrating toner I've ever used
- Too pricey tho
- **8/10**
-"
View thread →
"Can't believe that HaruHaru is only on 15, but whatever, this is an amazing analysis. Well done! 👏"
View thread →
"still love it. I will probably return to it in summer. But for now, the thicker HaruHaru toner is really serving my skin better."
View thread →
"Have you tried HaruHaru (yellow tube)? That is my favourite for a semi-matter natural finish."
View thread →
"made me laugh haha
I have oily skin, combo in the winter.. I’ve been using the HaruHaru sunscreen (the yellow one) and I like it! I used to use the Etude House Sunpris"
View thread →
"consumption & the same ingredients.
My last haul i bought 9 bottles of the HaruHaru black rice airyfit sunscreen at last years BF sales. This should last me til th"
View thread →
"th ‘enough’. i also enjoy the cosrx salicylic acid cleanser.
💧 water toner ; **haruharu black rice hyaluronic acid essence toner** - 9/10
this is beautiful. long-last"
View thread →
"ble. I know BoJ is a good intro brand but check out Shiseido, Numbazin, Purito, haruharu, Scinic, Round Lab, Shingmulnara, Isntree, Canmake…so many more. I still love &"
View thread →
"HaruHaru Black Rice Probiotics Barrier Essence!"
View thread →
"sensitive skin and this has never broken me out unlike others I have tried like haruharu and skin1004 cleansing oils. Emulsifies really nicely and feels so elegant.
I"
View thread →
"Toner and serum. Hada labo: Anti-Age serum. Beauty of joseon: niacinamid serum.
Haruharu: Black rice barrier essence - miracle when my skin is irritated)
Started 2 yea"
View thread →
"BOJ and Haruharu are my faves. Mixsoon is good too."
View thread →
"haruharu black rice cleansing gel (unscented). i have backups of this and i have repurch"
View thread →
"I will always stan HaruHaru, every single product I have used from this brand has been a medium to stellar"
View thread →
"my skin burns a little bit with both the BOJ and the skin1004 centella, but the haruharu moisture airyfit only ever feels nourishing and comfy! The only problem is that"
View thread →
"Haruharu has been getting me through my tretionoin dryness"
View thread →
"ng to find a picture where I had them all together, but can’t find it), I’d say haruharu essence and manyo panthetoin essence are my personal faves (I’m 36, have dry/no"
View thread →
"haruharu essence is a no brainer. i liked the keana rice masks too. it gently exfoliates"
View thread →
"k and both are good. I like that they’re thick and play nice around the eyes.
Haruharu rice cleanser: nice and gentle without being stripping. Love the balanced pH."
View thread →
"ent.
I'm disappointed I don't see iunik centella calming sunscreen. Iunik and haru haru wonder are my two favorite sunscreen brands."
View thread →
"Haruharu black rice toner. TOCOBO sunscreen. I’ve started buying this in multiples becau"
View thread →
"ell with layering. The one that resisted pilling and layering better for me was Haru Haru Wonder Airyfit. I ordered another tube. The only issue that I had was that the pump is"
View thread →
"- Kose softymo cleansing oil, any mild Korean cleanser (current favorite is the Haruharu black rice), occlude eyelids with Vaseline, tret, Aveeno baby eczema therapy cr"
View thread →
"as good as the Korean version, I’ve tried both. The one I got thru Amazon (the Haruharu store front) was much more water’y if that makes sense. Not as soothing and sof"
View thread →
"Honestly, Korean skincare (specifically Skin1004 and HaruHaru are a few of my favs) products have been what I have replaced all of my TO prod"
View thread →
"Just personal preference really. I like both. The haruharu one is a little thicker which I love"
View thread →
"d routine with layers. Get the Aestura Atobarrier 365 cream mist and cream plus HaruHaru Black Rice Essence. Layer them and I promise you’ll be good to go.
Also, are"
View thread →
"it's not as good as axis-y even many many hours later.
Ones such as Skin Aqua, Haruharu and BOJ aqua fresh always looked well at first, but throughout the day I'd be o"
View thread →
"Haru haru wonder airyfit spf. I’ve used it for awhile. I buy in batches. I have oily skin. For my"
View thread →
"hing BoJ. For som reason every product of theirs I tried just broke me out. The Haruharu probiotics essence toner, I’m from rice toner and innisfree cleansers. I love i"
View thread →
"+1 for Haruharu"
View thread →
"a boost of hydration and glow. Would you suggest the I'm From Rice toner or the HaruHaru black rice hyaluronic toner?"
View thread →
"Omi Sun Bears. Both are Matte and good under make up. If I want not too matte, haruharu/Laneige/Dr Althea."
View thread →
"moisturising for me. I think it didn't do much for me either.
Patch test the haruharu barrier essence too! I currently use it after the haruharu toner."
View thread →
"e I swear my face was brighter in the morning lol!...as well as anything from **HaruHaru**. Current rice products that I have been enjoying are several things from **Mi"
View thread →
"Haruharu Black Rice spf is a natural finish too! Just have to not mind the initial scent"
View thread →
"Haruharu Black Rice Probiotics Barrier Essence- it’s really hydrating and leaves my skin"
View thread →
"ean version. I buy it on YesStyle. But it has a dewy finish. For a satin finish Haru Haru Wonder Black Rice sunscreen."
View thread →
Buying decision
Who buys this, who regrets it.
A decision-oriented breakdown beyond the quotes — based on Reddit patterns and known issues.
Who it's for
- Dry skin and barrier-compromised types — most-hydrating toner per multiple Reddit reviewers
- Layering enthusiasts who want thicker viscosity than ordinary HA toners
- K-beauty brand-loyalists looking to build the full Haruharu routine
Who should skip
- Anyone with sensitive skin who reacted to the brand's probiotics essence — formulation overlap risk
- Budget shoppers — $25+ for a toner is steep vs The Ordinary alternatives at $8
- Amazon-only buyers — fake/diluted versions reported via the Haruharu Amazon storefront
Buying verdict
Buy if: dry skin, want a thicker hydrating toner, AND can source via YesStyle/Olive Young (not Amazon). Skip if: you reacted to the Probiotics Essence, you're budget-conscious, or you can only shop via Amazon.
Common complaints from Reddit
- SERIOUSAmazon storefront sells watery, inauthentic versions vs Korean original
- MEDIUMSister product (Probiotics Barrier Essence) caused severe irritation in sensitive skin
- MINORToo watery for some users — minimal noticeable effect
- MINORPrice point higher than comparable hydrating toners
⚠ Heads up
Amazon authenticity issue: the official Haruharu storefront on Amazon has been reported to ship a watery, less-effective formula vs the version sold via olive Young, YesStyle, or directly from Korea. If buying from Amazon, check seller is not 'haruharu wonder direct' (one of the flagged storefronts).
Threads tracked
The conversations we're watching.
Read also
Reddit deep-dives that mention this product.
Adjacent
Often mentioned in the same threads.
02
Aestura
Aestura atobarrier
Korean derma-brand barrier cream for dry skin and retinoid recovery nights.
★ · on Amazon
Buy on Amazon
See price
03
Beauty of Joseon
Relief Sun: Rice + Probiotics SPF50+
Lightweight Korean sunscreen that feels like nothing on skin—no white cast, applies clear in seconds.
★ · 462 Amazon reviews
Buy on Amazon
See price
