No. 19
in makeup
Buy on Amazon
See price
● Affiliate link.
We earn a commission on Amazon purchases — rankings are based on Reddit consensus, not commission rates.
How it works.
100% would recommend
Why we ranked it No. 19 in makeup
Sample
3 redditors with explicit opinion · 3 positive · 0 negative · 0 neutral
Score
1.000 — formula: 0.75 × % positive + 0.25 × pos/neg ratio
Confidence95% CI: 44–100% · the true approval rate falls in this range with 95% statistical confidence
Verdict
Early Signal — ≥75% positive but with <10 redditors — small sample, treat as a hint, not a verdict.
Sources
r/Makeup, r/DrugstoreMUA, r/curlyhair
Nyx · makeup
Early Signal
Butter Gloss
r/Makeupr/DrugstoreMUAr/curlyhair
TL;DR — Reddit consensus
Highly pigmented, buildable gloss at drugstore price. Can melt in your pocket from body heat.
What redditors love
+
Best pigmented gloss for the price
“Nyx butter gloss - best pigmented gloss”
u/slayingtbh · r/Makeup →
+
Buildable coverage lets you control intensity
“cheap, lightweight, can be built”
u/Unusual_Loquat480 · r/DrugstoreMUA →
+
Lightweight formula doesn't feel heavy
“cheap, lightweight, can be built”
u/Unusual_Loquat480 · r/DrugstoreMUA →
+
Creates shiny glossy effect over other lip products
“i applied some NYX Butter Gloss brownie dip for shiny effect”
u/NikkiSnel · r/curlyhair →
What they don’t
−
Melts in your pocket from body heat
“Nyx fat oil slick click - convenient but will melt in ur pocket”
u/slayingtbh · r/Makeup →
COMPARE WITH
Premium pick
Nars
Radiant Creamy Concealer
→
Direct quotes
What 3 redditors actually said.
Top 3 by confidence shown — expand below for the rest. Click any to open the original on Reddit.
S
u/slayingtbh
·
r/Makeup
nd color tho!
Nyx fat oil slick click - convenient but will melt in ur pocket
Nyx butter gloss - best pigmented gloss
Elf lip shine - cute balm, but not the best
Elf glow
U
u/Unusual_Loquat480
·
r/DrugstoreMUA
the recommendation! Here's a list of some of the most mentioned brands :)
1. [NYX Butter Gloss](http://hwturtle.com/go/B09SP2XHKT?p=kat) \- cheap, lightweight, can be built
N
u/NikkiSnel
·
r/curlyhair
iner NYX Line Loud Total baller + Isadora chocolate kiss 220 but i applied some NYX Butter Gloss brownie dip for shiny effect
https://preview.redd.it/k6tay9yfbdug1.jpeg?width=
Threads tracked
The conversations we're watching.
Read also
Reddit deep-dives that mention this product.
Adjacent
Often mentioned in the same threads.
02
Essence
Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
A $4-5 drugstore mascara that doesn't irritate sensitive eyes or cause lash shedding.
★ · 13.2k Amazon reviews
Buy on Amazon
See price
03
Nars
Radiant Creamy Concealer
High-coverage concealer that doesn't crease under eyes, beloved by users for nearly a decade.
★ · 6.7k Amazon reviews
Buy on Amazon
See price
