No. 04
in makeup
Buy on Amazon
See price
● Affiliate link.
We earn a commission on Amazon purchases — rankings are based on Reddit consensus, not commission rates.
How it works.
100% would recommend
Why we ranked it No. 4 in makeup
Sample
48 redditors with explicit opinion · 9 positive · 0 negative · 0 neutral
Score1.000 — formula: 0.75 × % positive + 0.25 × pos/neg ratio
Confidence95% CI: 70–100% · the true approval rate falls in this range with 95% statistical confidence
Verdict
Recommended — ≥50% positive. Mixed but more good than bad.
Sources
r/Makeup, r/drugstoreMUA, r/MakeupRehab, r/MakeupAddiction
REVLON · makeup
Recommended
Super Lustrous Lipstick
r/Makeupr/drugstoreMUAr/MakeupRehabr/MakeupAddiction
TL;DR — Reddit consensus
The $8 lipstick wall classic — Reddit's default answer for trying any color without commitment.
Reddit vs Amazon
Reddit's underrated favorite.
Reddit: 100% of 48 redditors recommend it.
Amazon: only ★4.6 from 40,594 reviews. Cult products with deep Reddit loyalty
often score lower on mass marketplaces — quirky packaging, specific use cases, slow ramp-up.
What redditors love
+
Massive shade range at drugstore price
“lot of odd looks for this one but i love it :) y'all were so supportive of my last look i've decided to do more! concealer: maybelline fit me shade 010 blush: revlon super lustrous creme lipstick shade rum rasin eyes and brows: nyx epic ink liner shade dark chocolate, morphe × james charles pallete,”
u/SadCatFriend · r/MakeupAddiction →
+
Comfortable non-drying classic formula
“lot of odd looks for this one but i love it :) y'all were so supportive of my last look i've decided to do more! concealer: maybelline fit me shade 010 blush: revlon super lustrous creme lipstick shade rum rasin eyes and brows: nyx epic ink liner shade dark chocolate, morphe × james charles pallete,”
u/SadCatFriend · r/MakeupAddiction →
What they don’t
−
Average wear time — expect touch-ups
Direct quotes
What 8 redditors actually said.
Top 6 by confidence shown — expand below for the rest. Click any to open the original on Reddit.
S
u/SadCatFriend
·
r/MakeupAddiction
lot of odd looks for this one but i love it :) y'all were so supportive of my last look i've decided to do more! concealer: maybelline fit me shade 010 blush: revlon super lustrous creme lipstick shade rum rasin eyes and brows: nyx epic ink liner shade dark chocolate, morphe × james charles pallete, loreal telescopic
P
u/Potential_Sundae_895
·
r/drugstoreMUA
liner! 1. peripera water bare tint: 06 2. peripera water bare tint: 05 3. nyx lingerie xxl liquid lipstick: deep mesh 4. nyx butter gloss: devil's food cake 5. revlon super lustrous lipstick: 777 vampire love 6. nyx butter gloss: rockyroad 7. wet n wild megalast lipstick: sasspot red 8. nyx butter gloss: red velvet 9.
I
u/ImLittleNana
·
r/Makeup
i love the butter glosses! my new favorite everyday lip is revlon super lustrous shine. the rerelease is in a white tube, the old ones are black tube. so very shiny, not sticky, no weird smell.
R
u/Revieme
·
r/Makeup
red cream blush — the best and so natural on me!) charlotte tilbury flawless filter (i use as a highlighter) milani make it last setting spray elf eyebrow gel revlon super lustrous lipstick in 08 ( love the formula and is blendable!) elf lip gloss (loving the strawberry color!) still finding my preferences for eyeshad
B
u/bee_wings
·
r/Makeup
good ol' revlon super lustrous lipsticks have been my go-to for a decade.
P
u/PrayStrayAndDontObey
·
r/MakeupRehab
ine winter iris quad:* goal: **use this 4 times.** progress: *1/4 uses.* 8. *jordana lipstick in bronze:* goal: **use this 3 times.** progress: *0/3 uses.* 9. *revlon super lustrous lipstick in love is on:* goal: **use this 3 times.** progress: *0/3 uses.* i see myself getting more progress with the moisturiser and ach
Threads tracked
The conversations we're watching.
●
r/MakeupAddiction
More Fun Graphic Eyeliner Got A Lot Of Odd Looks
●
r/drugstoreMUA
My Lippie Collection
●
r/Makeup
Is Elf The Best Affordable Makeup Brand Right Now
●
r/Makeup
What Would You Buy If You Lost All Your
●
r/Makeup
Give Me Your Best Traditional Lipstick
●
r/MakeupRehab
9 By New Years 2025 Update 1
●
r/MakeupRehab
9 By New Years 2025 Intro
●
r/drugstoreMUA
A Small Coupon Haul About 5 Out Of Pocket
Read also
Reddit deep-dives that mention this product.
Adjacent
Often mentioned in the same threads.
Out of stock on Amazon
02
URBAN DECAY
All Nighter Setting Spray
The setting spray Reddit names for events, heat and 12-hour days — the one Milani gets compared to.
★ · 1.7k Amazon reviews
Out of stock on Amazon
03
TIRTIR
Mask Fit Red Cushion
The viral red cushion — 54 redditors on the TikTok-famous glow finish; AI Overview names it the cushion to buy.
★ · 38.2k Amazon reviews
Buy on Amazon
See price
04
Milani
Make It Last Setting Spray
Drugstore setting spray 50 redditors swear keeps makeup through shifts and weddings — the budget Urban Decay rival.
★ · 35.9k Amazon reviews
Buy on Amazon
See price
Out of stock on Amazon
05
Milani
Baked Blush Luminoso
Cult drugstore baked blush — Luminoso is the shade Reddit names as the affordable NARS Orgasm energy.
★ · 30.7k Amazon reviews
Out of stock on Amazon